Wednesday, December 23, 2009
PS - Shout Out Time
Blue Like Jazz - These Words I'm Eating Are So Tasty
Tuesday, December 22, 2009
Proof God Loves Me and Wants Me To Be Happy
Every tear will be wiped away
knows there's bleeding to come
knows she's far from the only woman or girl
trusting this world no more than the hands
trust rusted barbed wire
Monday, December 21, 2009
On Being (Or Not Being) A Handmaid of The Lord: Thoughts on the Magnificat
There is a prolific amount of literature on the American book market revolving around proper womanhood as it relates to being a Christian. Many of these books have some kind of pink on their cover, or tend to involve flowers like roses. Or that stereotype of female Republicanism, pearls. They tend to be books of affirmation, as if trying to tell women that it’s ok that their lives are in a frazzle, because they’re serving, just like Jesus wants them to be. Or books promising to rescue them from feminism and shunt them back into being housewives through religious guilt. Never mind the reduced incomes of their families, or the fact that their spending might be too limited to buy books like these anymore. This cultural product of the white Victorian upper middle class a century or more ago must be preserved as the sacred will of God, like free market capitalism and the American flag. Or something.
The books for teenage girls are all about purity. Now, whenever someone talks about purity in the Christian sense I sort of want to throw myself down a flight of stairs. Purity is to me code for something that the people I love and I do not have and will never attain, no matter how hard we try. Purity is code for righteousness, judgment, and looking down on others in a Christian burden we’re-here-to-save-you-from-yourself kind of way. Purity is code for theology of glory.
Much ink has been spilled over the special meanings that purity has taken on for Christian girls. It makes me shudder in light of the fact that a girl or a woman has worth that is not and should not be based on her sexual purity (whatever THAT means). She has intrinsic worth based on her existence as a living human.
I spotted a book in the teen section of a Christian bookstore the other day that had the title “Guys Like Girls Who…” A handsome, relatively nonthreatening young man was on the cover. I suppressed a scream. Because I’m with the girls on the site Jezebel (ha) when it comes to this: we should define ourselves in terms of who we are and what we like, not in terms of what a man wants us to be.
Bbbut doesn’t Jesus want us to be a certain way? I hear some of you whimpering back there. Doesn’t Jesus want us to be his handmaids?
The word handmaid gives me flashbacks to Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale, where female fertility is rigidly controlled in an infertile, religious, fascist society. The title was totally intentional. I strongly suggest reading it.
Here’s the thing: if you’re female and straight, and you enter into a relationship with a man, he should respect you for who you are and love you for it. If you find yourself changing to be with him, then he is not the right one for you. The funny thing is, someone can tell you that and then turn around and act completely different. They can tell you all this stuff about how you should be your own person and then treat you like shit for not conforming to their standards of what they want you to be. And you can change and silence yourself out of love, and fear, and find yourself plunging into these ever-deeper waters of “If only I do this, maybe then things will get better.” But they won’t. Because the problem isn’t you. And by this time, you’re in so deep you can’t tell down from up anymore, the sun is just a vague memory, and you have to begin the painstaking work of getting back to the surface and reclaiming who you are. Simply because the man you were with didn’t recognize or give a damn about the value of it in the first place. And you feel shame and guilt for ever having experienced love for someone who valued you so little and treated you so poorly.
(I experienced this in my first serious relationship. Talk about messed up.)
We’re sold this package of heterosexual love and marriage by a culture that wants our buying power, our mental and physical energy, and our bodies but isn’t really interested in affirming who we are as people. American Christian culture gets even more insidious by imposing religious guilt in their insistence that we conform with this soul-crushing handmaidenhood, this uncomplaining wife and mother who will do whatever is asked of her by her husband, church, and community because it is the will of God.
People recoiled in horror at the wives on the YFZ ranch who were interviewed on national television following that raid on their compound in Texas. I wonder if some of those conservatives understand that this is what they’re asking for.
(The scary part would be finding out that yes, it is, and they’re okay with that.)
What is being a handmaid really about, though?
The word is used in the song traditionally known as the Magnificat (depending on your translation), sung by Mary when she goes to visit her cousin Elizabeth and understands this having the Messiah thing is the real deal. You can find it in Luke 1:46-55. It’s a text that is similar to that of the song of Hannah, who was a barren, middle-aged woman before God granted her a son, Samuel, who became the high priest of Israel in the Old Testament (1 Samuel 2:1-10). Both songs are about the mercy and power of God, and how he will give good things to the hungry, the lowly, the barren, while sending away the rich and powerful with nothing.
Richard Rohr, in his book Things Hidden, describes Mary as being the ultimate servant of God, who doesn’t ask “Why me?” or see herself as unworthy of God’s blessing; she accepts it with arms wide open, even at the risk she was taking in her own time and place in doing so (an engaged woman found to be pregnant before the wedding with another man’s child could have been sent home by her fiancĂ© and stoned to death under the law). She sees herself as being worthy of God’s blessing and her place in the making of the new covenant between God and the world. It is at once a humble, handmaidenly act. It is also up there with some of the bolder moves in the entire Bible. Without Mary, there wouldn’t have been an Incarnation, a Jesus. And the presence of Jesus as a Messiah in Mary’s culture? A BFD, as the kids say these days.
The Bible is quite littered with women making gutsy moves for God and Jesus, women killing men, aiding and abetting conquerors, going down to the empty tomb and then being loudmouthed about it, preaching the Word, messing with inheritances. There are a lot of infertile women having babies, a lot of prostitutes getting rewarded for their help.
Being a handmaid of God isn’t about conforming to societal norms. It’s not about purity (see St Paul and Martin Luther). It’s not about ‘proper womanhood’, or tied up with having the perfect house, perfect husband, perfect children, perfect life. It’s about having the guts to do the right thing and follow Christ.
At some point, maybe the cultural baggage surrounding following Christ will no longer include rampant consumerism, obsession with purity (hello? Grace anyone?), being judgmental, hatred, subsumed violence against women, and fear.
Following Christ involves servanthood, which rings of the collective boot that for a long time has been pressed into the neck of womankind. But it’s actually a rejection of the patriarchal violence of both the law and the trappings of the Roman Empire, both of which bled into the early church. It’s a rejection of the hatred of women that has permeated our culture for too long. The songs Hannah and Mary sing aren’t about the victory of the oppressors, the righteousness of the rich. They’re about the lowly being lifted up, the hungry being fed.
The impure having the blessing of God.
Following Christ is a call to see the divine in each person, male and female, because in Christ there is no male or female (Galatians 3:28). It’s a call to do justice, love mercy, and walk humbly with your God (Micah 6:8).
Now that’s something I can dig.